• Total Access Higher Safety
    Turner Access Chipmunk Data


    Firm failed to share information about fragile panels

    Dairy manufacturer, Muller UK and Ireland Group LLP, has been fined £400,000 after a worker suffered serious injuries when he fell some 5m through a fragile roof panel in July 2015.

    Manchester Crown Court heard that the worker was carrying out a routine job with two colleagues to change the refrigeration gas of the chilled storage units at the firm’s premises on Lake Road, Trafford Park.

    The workers were working in the roof void of the chilled store building above the chilled units.  One of the workers stood on a fragile fire board panel at the edge of the roof space and fell down the void between the chilled unit and the building shell. He suffered injuries to his head and body.

    Risk was not assessed adequately

    HSE investigators found that the workers had not been given any information from the company about the fragile roof panels in the void, despite having worked there on a number of previous occasions.

    The company had failed to carry out an adequate risk assessment prior to permitting access to the area and failed to share information about the presence of the fragile panels prior to the work being undertaken.

    The fragile panels were not clearly visible, had no warning markings and there were no barriers to prevent access to fragile areas.

    Muller UK and Ireland Group LLP, of Tern Valley Business Park, Shrewsbury Road, Market Drayton, pleaded guilty to breaching Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work, etc. Act 1974 and was fined £400,000 with £9,336.90 costs.

    HSE inspector Jane Carroll said after the hearing:

    “This case highlights how important it is that a suitable and sufficient risk assessment is undertaken for all work at height and work within roof voids, to identify the potential for fragile panels to be present.

    Falls from height through fragile roofs remain a common cause of life changing or fatal injuries for individuals at work”.


    Turner Access Chipmunk Data
    Total Access Higher Safety