Turner Access Higher Safety Total Access
Total Access Ethentic Chipmunk Data
Chipmunk Data Turner Access Ethentic

NO BLAME IF RISK ASSESSMENT ‘PROVED WRONG BY EVENTS’

Landowner cleared of negligence over death whilst HSE take action elsewhere

The High Court has found the National Trust was not negligent in respect of the death of child who died when struck by a falling tree branch in Norfolk in 2007.

Meanwhile,  in Cambridgeshire HSE inspectors investigating the death of the 13-year-old schoolgirl have recently issued an improvement notice to Yaxley Parish Council. The girl died at a Recreation Ground on June 30 2011 after a branch fell from a 50ft-high tree she was sitting beneath. A further branch fell from the tree the following week.

Paul Carter, HSE Principal Inspector said:

“The HSE served an improvement notice on Yaxley Parish Council on July 14 requiring it to make arrangements for the safe management of its tree stock. HSE will review its progress in achieving this in early August. There is a 21-day right of appeal and during this time it is inappropriate for HSE to comment further.”

Judge rules that National Trust “not negligent”

The High Court ruled that the National Trust was not to blame for the death of an 11-year-old schoolboy fatally crushed by a branch in woods in Norfolk. Daniel Mullinger, of West Bergholt, Essex, died and three children were injured at Felbrigg Hall, near Cromer, when the branch fell from a tree in 2007.

Daniel died instantly when the 21m branch fell from a 180-year-old beech tree in the Great Wood at the 17th Century stately home. His mother and three other families had sought compensation from the landowner, the National Trust. But all have lost their damages action. In a statement released through their solicitor the families said that it was “a difficult decision to accept”.

“The path where the accident occurred was upgraded to a medium risk path specifically because the paths under the tree were used by about 4,000 school children a year on organised trips. The families are very disappointed with the decision but it is unlikely there will be an appeal. Four years on this incident remains a very personal tragedy for the four families involved.”.

Lawyers argued that the tragedy would have been averted had inspectors spotted a defect in the ancient beech tree and “tagged” it for remedial action. Mr Justice Mackay said the decision that no action was needed in the event proved “wrong and disastrous consequences followed”.

Risk assessment can be proved wrong by events

Ruling in favour of the National Trust, the judge said it was “the cruelest coincidence” that the branch just happened to fall just as the school party passed beneath it. He added that even the most careful risk assessment can “by its very nature be proved wrong by events”. He also remarked that assessing the integrity of an ancient tree was “an art not a science”.

He concluded:

“I accept these inspectors used all the care to be expected of reasonably competent persons doing their job, and the National Trust had given them adequate training and instruction in how to approach their task. I regretfully conclude that I cannot find that the National Trust was negligent or in breach of its duty in respect of this tragedy”.

National Trust spokesman Nick Champion said:

“We hope that the case has provided some sense of relief and greater understanding. The judge ruling for the National Trust in no way undermines the great sense of personal tragedy that must be felt and our sympathies are with the families involved. It is important to the Trust that Mr Justice Mackay found our policies to be clear, robust and comprehensive. And we were reassured to hear that he felt that our tree inspections had been carried out competently.”

Latest Construction Health and Safety News

ROPE ACCESS WORKER FELL THROUGH FRAGILE ROOF

Prison sentence imposed on owner of rope access firm

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 24th April 2018

FIRMS FINED £2M OVER FALLING PIPE FATALITY

Incorrect stacking of pipes triggered fall and crushing of workman

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 20th April 2018

DOMESTIC PROJECT PC HANDED JAIL TERM

Workman fell from unprotected roof edge on dormer extension

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 20th April 2018

MAJOR CONTRACTOR ERRED ON FRAGILE ROOF RISK

Firms fine £965,000 after painter fell through waiting room roof

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 19th April 2018

HSE ENFORCEMENT UPDATE 19th APRIL 2018

hselogo1Prosecutions and enforcement notices update and analysis

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 19th April 2018

STRUCTURAL SAFETY BODY LATEST NEWSLETTER

CROSS publishes reports and expert comment on a range of issues

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 18th April 2018

NEW BIM SPEC FOR SHARING H&S INFORMATION

Specification for sharing health and safety info during construction projects

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 17th April 2018

MANAGERS FORGED ASBESTOS DOCUMENTATION

Removal licence obtained using fake training and medical certificates

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 17th April 2018

FINE OVER INCORRECT AND MISLEADING SURVEY

Specialist asbestos company failed to detect AIB on demolition project

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 17th April 2018

IGNORING HSE ADVICE PENALISED BY LARGE FINE

Contractor fined over £50k for persistent WAH and welfare failings

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 17th April 2018

PRISON OVER BASEMENT EXCAVATION AND COLLAPSE

Building contractor jailed after house collapsed in Brighton

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 17th April 2018

DEFEATING POWER INTERLOCK CAUSED FLASHOVER

Systems for managing electrical safety found to be inadequate

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 17th April 2018

LADDER SAFETY FAILURES ATTRACT MASSIVE FINE

National window firm left workers to ‘own devices’

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 12th April 2018

FALLING MATERIAL STRUCK WORKMAN IN EXCAVATION

Risks of working in and near excavations highlighted by incident

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 4th April 2018

HSE ENFORCEMENT WEEKLY UPDATE 4th APRIL 2018

hselogo1Prosecutions and enforcement notices weekly update and analysis

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 4th April 2018

HOUSING ASSOCIATION FAILED ON VIBRATION RISK

Assessment, management and health surveillance all found wanting

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 3rd April 2018

OCCUPIER AND CONTRACTOR FINED OVER FALL

Employee assisting contractor fell through roof during re-roofing project

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 3rd April 2018

HSE FEARFUL OF GROWING ’BLUE TAPE’ BURDEN

hselogo1ISO 45001 could generate fresh business to business demands

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 3rd April 2018

HSE ENFORCEMENT WEEKLY UPDATE 21st MAR 2018

hselogo1Prosecutions and enforcement notices weekly update and analysis

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 28th March 2018

INCIDENTS: PASSER-BY STRUCK BY BRICKS

Pack of bricks appear to have fallen from crane

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 28th March 2018

HSE RECONSIDER HOW TO INFLUENCE SMALLER FIRMS

hselogo1Regulator advice and messages are failing to chime with the SME businesses

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 27th March 2018

DANGEROUS REMOVAL OF ASBESTOS CEMENT

Workers smashed asbestos sheets with crowbars whilst at risk of falling

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 27th March 2018

HSE LAUNCH CONIAN SHARING AND SUPPORT PLATFORM

hselogo1New HSE web community now open to the public

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 27th March 2018

FIRM FAILING ON HAVS SURVEILLANCE FINED £50,000

Door manufacturer failed to manage sanding and buffing tool vibration

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 27th March 2018

PRE-CAST FIRM FINED OVER FINGER AMPUTATION

Lack of guarding and training triggered table saw injury

Read the rest of this article »

Posted on 26th March 2018
Turner Access Chipmunk Data
Total Access Ethentic
Higher Safety Turner Access