Ethentic Ethentic Higher Safety Higher Safety Chipmunk Data Chipmunk Data
  • Higher Safety Higher Safety Chipmunk Data Chipmunk Data Ethentic Ethentic

    SAFETY NETS HOLD UP UNDER SCRUTINY OF RESEARCH

    Combined fall of both materials and worker into safety nets is ‘problematic’

    HSE has published the results of research evaluating the effectiveness of safety nets to identify the risk (if any) of premature failure. There is little historical information on the effectiveness of nets and an incident at Old Trafford, raised concerns about their performance in non-ideal loading situations (ie pre-existing damage, sharp or heavy material entering the net or variations in installation practices).

    Given the increased emphasis on safety nets the research aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of safety nets, as used in the UK, and to identify the risk (if any) of premature failure in the less than ideal situations that could occur in the workplace.

    The project included a range of variables including:

    • net material and manufacture (knotted or knotless nets);
    • effect of falling onto different positions in the net such as edges and corners;
    • spacing of the attachment points;
    • effect of repeated dynamic loading at one position (to simulate multiple falls);
    • effect of differently shaped items falling into the net;
    • effect of sag in the net;
    • use of alternative techniques to control sag in oversized nets;
    • presence of defects; and
    • effects of ageing and degradation due to ongoing service damage and the effectiveness of test meshes in monitoring degradation

    To evaluate these variables a range of tests were carried out using a purpose built drop facility at HSL, Buxton. The resulting loads were measured at various positions around the periphery of the net and damage to the net monitored.

    Conclusions

    The research report draws the following conclusions (bold text NOT in report) :

    • The safety nets used, generally withstood multiple tests, with penetration occurring only in unusual circumstances. No serious safety concerns were identified.
    • The larger the attachment spacing, the higher the load at the attachment point and the greater the displacement of the net under load.
    • The highest peak loads are generally recorded adjacent to the drop point.
    • Peak loads are generally higher for drops at centres of edges and lower for drops at corners.
    • Load is transmitted along linear axes from the point of drop, which is likely to be an effect of the square mesh configuration.
    • Where damage to the net occurred, it was more likely to occur at attachment points than at drop points.
    • There were no significant trends in performance differences between any of net types.
    • The highest load on a first drop was 4.84 kN, well below the 6 kN characteristic limit.
    • There was a cumulative reduction in elasticity on repeated drops into a safety net. FASET guidance is that nets which have experienced a dynamic load should be replaced.
    • The calculated sag was not necessarily evident in the suspended safety net. Inducing extra sag into the net, increased the displacement of the net under load but didn’t have a significant effect on loading.
    • The FASET recommended technique of under-rolling excess netting did not produce significantly different results to the alternative technique of gathering. However, under-rolling is a more controllable and should remain the preferred option.
    • Small defects at the drop point represented a potential source of failure on repeat dropping. However, small defects at the attachment point increased displacement under load but did not represent a source of failure.
    • All retained items tended to move towards the centre of the net. The 95%-ile test dummy moved more erratically than the sphere.
    • The test dummy induced higher loading on the net than the BS EN 1263-1 sphere. While this may be a more realistic test, the dummy’s erratic movement makes it less controllable.
    • The safety nets were incapable of retaining the compact mass of the 100 kg cylinder. The possibility of aggressive material (such as heavy and compact or sharp edged objects) entering the net with a falling worker remains a concern.
    • Despite the poor condition of the nets tested in phase 3, intact mesh samples retained between 67% and 97% of their estimated original strength.
    • The mesh retained its properties even in close proximity to areas of damage. Significant deterioration in performance, only occurred when there was obvious damage to the net sample.
    • There was consistent agreement between test meshes results and net samples from within the net indicating that test meshes provide a realistic predictor of net performance.
    Recommendations for further work
    1. This programme was specified to “sample” a wide range of variables and has identified several areas where further consideration and more detailed investigation may be required.
    2. Investigation of the loads experienced by a falling body on entering a safety net, using an instrumented test dummy. The erratic movement of the test dummy and resulting damage may indicate that workers entering a net may be at risk of injury.
    3. Comparison with the loads on a net resulting from a body falling into the net from greater heights. Personnel working above the recommended UK working limit of 2 m may be a foreseeable misuse.
    4. Investigation of the effects of damage (such as damage from hot work or abrasion) on small scale material samples. In the absence of a reliable source of samples from industry (such as was encountered during phase 3 of this programme) damage could be artificially introduced.
    5. Further investigation into the behaviour of “real” construction materials entering nets. The 100 kg cylinder penetrated the net on every test, retention of other construction material, which could easily enter the net with falling personnel, could prove similarly problematic.

    Latest Construction Health and Safety News

    ARM DRAGGED INTO CONVEYOR BELT DANGER

    Workman seriously injured on first day at work in quarry

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 16th January 2019

    ROOF TRUSSES TOPPLED TRAPPING WORKMAN

    Principal contractor failed to plan, manage and monitor project

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 16th January 2019

    SCAFFOLDING AWARENESS TRAINING FOR ALL

    CISRS set to target painters, bricklayers, electricians and plumbers

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 16th January 2019

    HSE ENFORCEMENT DATABASE REMAINS OFFLINE

    hselogo1Access to HSE prosecutions and notices register mysteriously unavailable

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 15th January 2019

    POOR LIFT MAINTENANCE CLAIMED LIFE OF CHILD

    Affordable housing business and contractor fined over £1.5m

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 15th January 2019

    NEW CPA CRANE SAFETY GUIDANCE ISSUED

    Guide covers use of mobile lifting appliances beside railways

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 14th January 2019

    RIBA CONDEMNS RISKIER PROCUREMENT OUTCOMES

    Holistic focus on safety is required and not just cost cutting

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 8th January 2019

    DIRECTOR JAILED OVER PAINT STRIPPER ILLEGAL SALE

    Banned and restricted chemicals sold contrary to legal requirements

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 5th January 2019

    CLIENT FAILED TO PROCURE ASBESTOS SURVEY

    Demolition work released large quantities of asbestos fibres

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 2nd January 2019

    LIVE WORKING IGNITED CLOTHES OF ELECTRICIAN

    Spanner came into contact with live terminal causing life-changing burns

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 31st December 2018

    WORKMEN FELL FROM ‘BIN’ ATTACHED TO EXCAVATOR

    Premature removal of scissor lift prompted unsafe system of work

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 31st December 2018

    MANY SITES FAIL HSE HEALTH RISK CONTROL TEST

    HSE Construction site ‘blitz’ finds breaches at 43% of site visits

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 31st December 2018

    MAKESHIFT FALL ARREST SYSTEM CAUGHT ON CAMERA

    Contactors fined for using harness not attached to suitable anchor

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 31st December 2018

    HYDRAULIC RAM SEVERED HAND OF WORKMAN

    Major contractor failed to follow own policies and procedures

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 31st December 2018

    ALL WORK AREAS NOT INCLUDED IN ASBESTOS SURVEY

    Company fined after asbestos containing materials were released

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 31st December 2018

    FESTIVE GREETINGS TO ALL OUR READERS

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th December 2018

    POSITIVE STORY ON FRAGILE SURFACE HAZARDS

    Major roofing contractor testifies to working from below roof

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th December 2018

    LEISURE CENTRE USER FELL ILL AFTER SHOWER USE

    Legionella risk assessment and control measures found wanting

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th December 2018

    STONE CUTTING MACHINE GUARDS FAILED HSE TEST

    Precautions taken following HSE enforcement fell into disuse

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th December 2018

    ROOFWORK CREATED CARBON MONOXIDE RISK

    Falling rubble damaged and blocked home chimney flue

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th December 2018

    HSE SAFETY ALERT: TOWER CRANE BRAKES

    Collapse of tower crane jib in high winds prompts HSE warning

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 11th December 2018

    VISITING ENGINEER CRUSHED BY SCAFFOLD TUBES

    Principal contractor “signed off” contractor storage arrangements

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 11th December 2018

    CONCRETE EJECTED BY PUMPING UNIT CLAIMED LIFE

    Company and director failed to train and supervise pumping operations

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 5th December 2018

    REFRESHED GUIDANCE ON FITNESS TO OPERATE PLANT

    Construction plant medical fitness Good Practice Guide

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 4th December 2018

    MAJOR CONTRACTOR & LUL USED UNSAFE SYSTEM

    Work method to eliminate moving vehicle hazard not adopted

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 4th December 2018
    Ethentic Ethentic Higher Safety Higher Safety Chipmunk Data Chipmunk Data
  • Higher Safety Higher Safety Chipmunk Data Chipmunk Data Ethentic Ethentic