![PP Construction Safety logo and link to home page [1]](http://www.ppconstructionsafety.com/wp-content/themes/ppcs960/images/ppcslogo.jpg)
DOMESTIC CLIENT RESPONSIBILITY FOR CONTRACTOR SAFETY
Worker injury claim against homeowner highlights CDM domestic client debate
The Daily Mail has reported on a High Court case in which an injured builder is pursuing a claim for damages against the domestic client on whose property he was injured.
The claimant alleges that he was standing on a ladder belonging to the client whilst holding a roll of roofing material which he intended to pass up to a colleague on the roof of the garage. The ladder toppled over and he fell to the ground.
Following a High Court hearing in March 2010 the written judgement by The Hon Mrs Justice Swift DBE found in favour of the homeowner. However, Tomasz Kmeicic (aged 31) has now been granted permission for the matter to heard by the Court of Appeal.
Householders will greet case with ‘horror’
Robin Allen QC, for Mr Kmiecic, said the case would:
“provide an excellent opportunity to give a definitive ruling on the extent of householders’ duties towards workmen”.
At the earlier High Court hearing, Mrs Justice Swift suggested that the real culprit was the uninsured building contractor who had engaged Mr Kmeicic.
In granting the appeal she added that the issue raised points of European law never before considered by the courts and noted that the case would be ‘greeted with some degree of horror’ by many householders.
Comment
This case is a reminder of similar possible developments in relation to the statute law, namely the CDM Regulations 2007.
The Temporary or Mobile Construction Sites Directive was implemented in the UK through the CDM Regulations 2007. However, the UK approach to implementation of the Directive exempted domestic clients from CDM client duties whilst no such exemption exists in the Directive.
Policymakers in the UK felt it would not be “practical, proportionate, politically acceptable or enforceable to place duties on true domestic clients”.
The approach adopted by the UK and others is still being reviewed by the EU. Domestic construction clients could still in the future find themselves facing responsibility for contractor safety on both civil and statutory fronts!
Latest Construction Health and Safety News
HSE ENFORCEMENT DATABASE LATEST UPDATE
View current online register of HSE prosecutions and enforcement notices
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 14th August 2019FALL PRECAUTIONS FELL BETWEEN TWO FIRMS
Contractors fined after workers at risk of falling from roof
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 9th August 2019SOLAR PANEL FIRM AWARE OF FRAGILE ROOF RISK
Workman suffered long-term injuries in 4m fall through rooflight
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 9th August 2019HSE PROSECUTE FIRM OVER RISK NOT HARM
Multiple safety failings land construction company in court
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 9th August 2019CLIENT AND CONTRACTOR FACED COURT TOGETHER
Firms breached joint duty to plan and carry our work at height safely
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 6th August 2019£1M FINE OVER DEATH CAUSED BY EXCAVATOR
Vehicle driver found guilty at trial alongside CDM Principal Contractor
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 6th August 2019CHILD DIED WHILST PLAYING ON POWERED GATE
Lack of end stop caused gate to fall on 6 year old boy
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 6th August 2019HSE SPEAK AT ACCESS INDUSTRY CONFERENCE 2019
AIF National Working at Height Conference November 2019
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 6th August 2019UK CLIENT FINED OVER UNSAFE OVERSEAS FIRM
Italian contractor found guilty despite failure to attend court
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 6th August 2019COMPLETE FAILURE TO RECOGNISE HAVS RISK
Specialist drilling company and director sentenced over HAVS danger
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 6th August 2019PC AND TWO OTHERS FAILED TO ASSESS WIND EFFECT
Fall of director from roof caused by ‘Storm Doris’ gust
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 30th July 2019MAJOR FIRM FINED £400k OVER LIFTING OPERATION
Fitter loses four fingers as load slides and falls to the ground
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 28th July 2019NEW HOMES LEFT IN DANGEROUS CONDITION
Fined for unsafe gas work causing fires at housing development
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 28th July 2019FIRM FINED £1M OVER EXPLOSION DURING CLEANING
Tank cleaning operation caused burns as flammable vapours ignited
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 25th July 2019YOUNG BRICKLAYER FELL THROUGH OPEN STAIRWAY
Firm fined over failure to install fall protection around opening
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 25th July 2019STRUCTURAL SAFETY BODY LATEST NEWSLETTER
CROSS publishes reports and expert comment on a range of issues
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 23rd July 2019FLAT ROOF FAILED UNDER WEIGHT OF WORKMAN
Confusion over fragility proves costly for worker and business
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 23rd July 2019PROPERTY FIRM FINED OVER FATAL FALL FROM TREE
Untrained workers using chain saw engaged to fell large sycamore
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 23rd July 2019LANDLORD PUT PUBLIC AT RISK FROM ASBESTOS
Powered jet washing of asbestos cement sheets caused spread
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 23rd July 2019WORKMAN FELL FROM SUSPENDED ACCESS EQUIPMENT
Health Board and maintenance firm director prosecuted
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 23rd July 2019CONSIDERING TEMP WORKS IN PERMANENT DESIGN
Useful overview for civil and structural engineers on contemporary practice
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 23rd July 2019FIRM FAILED TO COMPLY WITH SITE WELFARE NOTICE
Basic welfare requirements found wanting for second time
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 23rd July 2019PRISON TERM OVER POORLY GUARDED CIRCULAR SAW
Workman lost three fingers using machine without guard and riving knife
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 23rd July 2019COMPANY IGNORED HSE ON SILICA DUST ACTION
Worktop manufacturer failed to control dust and manage ventilation
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 23rd July 2019ASBESTOS REMOVED WITHOUT SURVEY OR CONTROLS
Client fined over failure to commission refurb and demo survey
Posted on 15th July 2019
