![PP Construction Safety logo and link to home page [1]](http://www.ppconstructionsafety.com/wp-content/themes/ppcs960/images/ppcslogo.jpg)
DOMESTIC CLIENT RESPONSIBILITY FOR CONTRACTOR SAFETY
Worker injury claim against homeowner highlights CDM domestic client debate
The Daily Mail has reported on a High Court case in which an injured builder is pursuing a claim for damages against the domestic client on whose property he was injured.
The claimant alleges that he was standing on a ladder belonging to the client whilst holding a roll of roofing material which he intended to pass up to a colleague on the roof of the garage. The ladder toppled over and he fell to the ground.
Following a High Court hearing in March 2010 the written judgement by The Hon Mrs Justice Swift DBE found in favour of the homeowner. However, Tomasz Kmeicic (aged 31) has now been granted permission for the matter to heard by the Court of Appeal.
Householders will greet case with ‘horror’
Robin Allen QC, for Mr Kmiecic, said the case would:
“provide an excellent opportunity to give a definitive ruling on the extent of householders’ duties towards workmen”.
At the earlier High Court hearing, Mrs Justice Swift suggested that the real culprit was the uninsured building contractor who had engaged Mr Kmeicic.
In granting the appeal she added that the issue raised points of European law never before considered by the courts and noted that the case would be ‘greeted with some degree of horror’ by many householders.
Comment
This case is a reminder of similar possible developments in relation to the statute law, namely the CDM Regulations 2007.
The Temporary or Mobile Construction Sites Directive was implemented in the UK through the CDM Regulations 2007. However, the UK approach to implementation of the Directive exempted domestic clients from CDM client duties whilst no such exemption exists in the Directive.
Policymakers in the UK felt it would not be “practical, proportionate, politically acceptable or enforceable to place duties on true domestic clients”.
The approach adopted by the UK and others is still being reviewed by the EU. Domestic construction clients could still in the future find themselves facing responsibility for contractor safety on both civil and statutory fronts!
Latest Construction Health and Safety News
REVERSING TELEHANDLER CAUSED SITE DEATH
Principal Contractor and contractor held jointly responsible
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 26th May 2017PLANNING AND DESIGN ERRORS BEHIND FOUR DEATHS
Prison sentence and fines follow steel cage collapse tragedy
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 26th May 2017FAILED HSE SITE INSPECTION ENDS IN COURT
Injury not required for accountability over poor safety standards
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 26th May 2017RISK ASSESSMENT BREACH PROMPTS £400,000 FINE
Fatality revealed assessment was not suitable and sufficient
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 24th May 2017HSE ENFORCEMENT WEEKLY UPDATE 24th MAY 2017
Prosecutions and enforcement notices weekly update and analysis
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 24th May 2017LACK OF SAFE PLATFORMS FOR WORK ON CRANE
Major crane hire company erred on work at height precautions
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 22nd May 2017SECOND CORPORATE MANSLAUGHTER CASE IN WEEK
Double fatality represented pattern of serious neglect
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 22nd May 2017DIRECTORS JAILED AND FIRM FINED FOR MANSLAUGHTER
Client paid £100,000 less than economic cost for roof work
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 22nd May 2017SOLAR PANEL FIRM AND DIRECTOR IN COURT
Ineffective use of fall arrest no substitute for proper precautions
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 22nd May 2017FIRM FAILED TO SECURE COMPETENT ASSISTANCE
Court holds manager to account over inaction on risk management
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 22nd May 2017HSE ENFORCEMENT WEEKLY UPDATE 17th MAY 2017
Prosecutions and enforcement notices weekly update and analysis
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 21st May 2017HSE ENFORCEMENT WEEKLY UPDATE 10th MAY 2017
Prosecutions and enforcement notices weekly update and analysis
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 12th May 2017GROUND WORKER TRAPPED BY EXCAVATION COLLAPSE
Fellow workers dug earth so injured workman could breath
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 11th May 2017MAJOR UK FIRMS FAILED ON VEHICLE MANAGEMENT
Worker struck and injured when towed trolley and load overturned
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 9th May 2017MAGISTRATES FINE FIRM £250,000 OVER ROOF FALL
Solar panel firm failed to control risk and supervise works
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 9th May 2017HSE REFURBISHMENT CAMPAIGN ENDS £750,000 FINE
Contractor fined under CDM after failing to act on asbestos survey
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 8th May 2017SITE MANAGER JAILED OVER DEATH OF PASSER-BY
Failure to secure windows led to death and manslaughter sentence
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 8th May 2017ROGUE GAS FITTER JAILED FOR 16 MONTHS
Work unsafe and exposed home residents at risk of harm
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 3rd May 2017LADDER ASSOCIATION ISSUES NEW SAFETY GUIDANCE
Guidance comes amidst concerns surrounding unsafe telescopic ladders
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 3rd May 2017FATALITY: FALL ON NEW HOMES PROJECT
Workman died falling from a ladder on construction project
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 3rd May 2017FIRM ADMITS GUILT AFTER DEATH OF FOUR WORKMEN
Guilty plea entered by company on first day of Crown Court trial
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 3rd May 2017FIRM FINED £2 MILLION OVER WORKPLACE DEATH
Unsafe stacking of plastic bales claimed life of cleaner
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 3rd May 2017HSE ENFORCEMENT WEEKLY UPDATE 1st MAY 2017
Prosecutions and enforcement notices weekly update and analysis
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 3rd May 2017CONCRETE STAIRCASE CAUSED FATAL CRUSHING
Lifting operations were unsafe and poorly supervised on project
Read the rest of this article »
Posted on 3rd May 2017CALL TO HALT FALL IN HSE FRONT LINE INSPECTORS
Union reveals 25% cut and increasing delay in concluding investigations
Posted on 3rd May 2017
