• Higher Safety Higher Safety Chipmunk Data Chipmunk Data

    A LEGAL EAGLE WRITES

    Recent prosecutions suggest offences heard at ‘wrong’ venue?

    We have received the following from a solicitor, specialising in health and safety law, drawing attention to recent fines in HSE construction sector prosecutions.

    “In 1998 the Court of Appeal, in the case of R v F Howe (Engineers) Ltd, said “In our judgment magistrates should always think carefully before accepting jurisdiction in health and safety at work cases where … … serious injury has resulted from the offence”

    The Prosecutor, e.g. HSE, is entitled, and invited, to make representations to the magistrates as to whether they should retain jurisdiction or send a case to the Crown Court which can impose unlimited fines.

    The following recent cases (see HSE Construction Infonet October 2009) suggest that magistrates are retaining jurisdiction even where serious injuries have resulted from the offences.

    • Gateshead Magistrates’ 29.9.09: HSW Act. Serious incident. Fall 7m metres to the warehouse floor, sustaining serious injuries. Fines: Company £6k and Director £1k
    • Liverpool Magistrates’ 8.10.09: WAH Regulations 2005. Serious injury. Fell approximately 6m. Suffered back injuries in the fall and fractured his pelvis and chest. Long-term psychological effect. Unable to return to work. Fines: Company £3.5k
    • Newcastle-under-Lyme Magistrates’ 16.10.09: HSW Act. Fall fom the first floor, suffering life-threatening injuries. Fines:Company £8k
    • Norwich Magistrates’ 22.10.09: HSW Act. Fractured spine and metal disk required in back. Unable to work for a year and lost his sense of taste and smell. Fines: Sole trader £7.5k
    • Redditch Magistrates’ 15.10.09: HSW Act. Burns to 52 per cent of body and heart re-started. Fines: Company1 £11.9k, Company 2 £5.9k, Director of Company 2 £5.9k

    In 1998 the Court of Appeal said “Disquiet has been expressed in several quarters that the level of fine for health and safety offences is too low. We think there is force in this and that the figures with which we have been supplied support the concern”.

    The figures supplied to the Court showed that the average fine in the magistrates’ courts for breaches of the duties under sections 2 and 3 was £2,110 in 1992/93 and this had risen to £6,223 by 1998 whereas in the Crown Court the 1997/98 average fine per offence was £17,768.

    It might be as a result of the recession but clearly there has not been much change in the last 10 years.”

    Comment: These recent cases were all heard in the magistrates courts despite the apparent seriousness of the injury. There are at least two possible explanations: (a) HSE inspectors did not make representations that the cases be heard in the crown court or (b) the magistrate, having heard the facts, concluded that the overall seriousness of the offence and culpability of the offender were less than might first appear. 

    Latest Construction Health and Safety News

    CONSTRUCTION SAFETY NEWS – END OF NEW CONTENT

    The addition of content on this website ceased on 17th April 2020.

    Material posted before this date can be found by clicking on our SEARCH NEWS DATABASE function.

    Posted on 3rd May 2020

    HSE WARN OF NEED FOR RPE FACE FIT TEST AND CHECK

    Incorrectly fitted RPE will not protect the wearer from dangers to health

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 16th April 2020

    CORONA VIRUS: LATEST SITE OPERATING PROCEDURES

    Industry Bodies publish risk management guidance Version 3

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 15th April 2020

    TOWER CRANE OUT OF SERVICE SAFETY ALERT

    Important advice from Construction Plant-hire Association and HSE

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 30th March 2020

    FRAGILE ROOF REPLACEMENT PUT WORKERS IN DANGER

    Measures to prevent falling from or through the roof were missing

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 30th March 2020

    WORKMAN FELL FROM EDGE OF MEZZANINE FLOOR

    Edge protection was absent and workman untrained for the task

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 30th March 2020

    HSE PLAN AND CONSTRUCTION PRIORITIES 2020/21

    Appointed CDM 2015 Principal Designers remain focus of HSE inspections

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 30th March 2020

    COVID-19 ADVICE & GUIDANCE FOR CONSTRUCTION

    BuildUK support industry with advice, guidance and information

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 30th March 2020

    LATEST HSE CONVICTIONS AND NOTICES REGISTERS

    hselogo1View current online HSE registers of prosecution convictions and notices

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 30th March 2020

    POORLY DESIGNED SCHOOL GATE CRUSHED CHILD

    Sliding gate over-run mechanism proved insufficiently robust

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 9th March 2020

    POWER GENERATOR PROSECUTED OVER UNSAFE SYSTEM

    Maintenance workers seriously injured when energy suddenly released

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 2nd March 2020

    CEILING BELOW SAVES WORKMAN IN ROOFLIGHT FALL

    Roofworker fell through roof after stepping on fragile rooflight

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 2nd March 2020

    INEXPERIENCED WORKER FELL THROUGH OPENING

    No physical protection or warning of opening and fragile covering

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 29th February 2020

    CDM PRINCIPAL DESIGNER IN COURT OVER FIRE RISK

    Designers and contractor prosecuted for risk management failings

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 29th February 2020

    PRISON SENTENCE FOR RECALCITRANT DIRECTOR

    Prohibition and improvement notices ignored and danger persisted

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 26th February 2020

    TEMPORARY WORKS HOARDING FELL ON PEDESTRIAN

    Member of the public struck when site fence collapsed suddenly

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 26th February 2020

    CHILD FATALLY INJURED BY UNSECURED POLE

    Pole stored on embankment moved and trapped boy against fencing

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 26th February 2020

    OWNER RESPONSE TO HSE INSPECTION ENDED IN COURT

    Police uphold HSE right to inspect without threats, aggression or abuse

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 24th February 2020

    HSE TARGETING WELDING FUME CANCER RISK

    Inspections to enforce improved controls required by new risk evidence

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 24th February 2020

    CONTRACTOR FAILED TO REPLACE MISSING PROTECTION

    Painter and decorator fractured hip in fall from landing

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th February 2020

    RISK OF DERMATITIS SUFFICIENT FOR PROSECUTION

    Company failed to implement controls and surveillance required by COSHH

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th February 2020

    COSHH FAILINGS CAUSE ASTHMA AND PROVE COSTLY

    Uncontrolled exposure to isocyanates during paint spraying operations

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th February 2020

    POLICE EMPLOYEE SHOCKED BY DATA CABLE WORK

    South Wales Force fined over electric shock from ceiling void cable

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th February 2020

    COLLAPSE OF PUMP SET TRAPPED WORKMAN

    Unsafe system of work transferring from pallet to a raised platform

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 18th February 2020

    MODIFIED PODIUM STEPS CAUSE FALL FROM HEIGHT

    Firm failed to select and correctly assemble with necessary training

    Read the rest of this article »

    Posted on 14th February 2020
  • Higher Safety Higher Safety Chipmunk Data Chipmunk Data